Vicky Alvear Shecter

Official Author Site

  • Author
    • Contact Vicky
  • YA Historical Fiction
    • Cleopatra’s Moon
    • Curses and Smoke: A Novel of Pompeii
  • Mythology
    • Anubis Speaks: A Guide to the Afterlife by the Egyptian God of the Dead
    • Hades Speaks: A Guide to the Underworld by the Greek God of the Dead
    • Thor Speaks: A Guide to the Norse Realms by the Viking God of Thunder
  • Biography
    • Warrior Queens: True Stories of Six Ancient Rebels Who Slayed History
    • Cleopatra Rules! The Amazing Life of the Original Teen Queen
    • Alexander the Great Rocks the World
  • Adult Historical Fiction
    • A Day of Fire: A Novel of Pompeii
    • A YEAR OF RAVENS: A NOVEL OF BOUDICA’S REBELLION
    • A SONG OF WAR: A NOVEL OF TROY
    • A Sea of Sorrow: A Novel of Odysseus
  • Blog
    • Video
    • Teachers

1 Comment

Wait, This is a CHILD, not Circe!

At first I was beguiled by the sweet intensity and realness of the girl in this image from The Met Collection . Then I saw the artist’s title for the photograph: CIRCE.

I immediately went into mama-lionness mode: This is a CHILD! Why would the photographer name her after the wily, sexual witch who turned men into pigs and kept Odysseus in her bed?!

Remember this photo Carroll took of young Alice Liddell?

Sexualizing children, it seems, has a long tradition. The photograph is dated to 1865.  Imagine my surprise to find that the artist was a woman–Julia Margaret Cameron. I had assumed it had been taken by a Lewis Caroll-like character (see photo on right for the inspiration for Alice in Wonderland).

Discovering the artist was a woman does not mitigate the problematic nature of sexualizing young girls.

Now, the artist could have called the photograph, “Young Circe.” Then the child’s open, guileless innocence would make sense–this is the face of a girl who does not yet know that she will be called a witch or a “dreadful goddess” because she dares to live under no man’s rule. She does not yet know that her island of peace will be invaded by sailors who could do her serious harm.

She does not yet know that the only tool she has available for protection (her magic) will be disabled by a male god in favor of the man who invades her isle, Odysseus. She does not yet know that this same god–Hermes–will tell Odysseus that when she tries to protect herself with her staff, he must  draw his “sharpened sword and rush at her as if you mean to kill her. She will be frightened with you and will tell you to sleep with her.” Book 10 from Emily Wilson’s translation of Homer’s Odyssey.

Yeah, because that’s what women do when they’re rushed at with a drawn weapon–“tell” their attackers to sleep with them.

Who has the power here? She may have been called a witch-goddess, but Odysseus was given the power and  means to conquer her. More like, Circe agrees to sleep with him in order to, you know, not be killed.

But yeah, she “tells” Odysseus to sleep with her. But before he “deigns” to do so, he makes her take an oath–likely with the point of his sword still to her neck–to not to hurt him or his men. She agrees.

From the male-centric point of view, Odysseus “conquers” the wily, witchy sex goddess. From the female perspective, I dunno, it sounds a lot like rape ( a woman acquiescing to sexual demands in exchange for continuing to breathe). Libbie Hawker’s take on Circe’s story brilliantly conveys  the nuances in Circe’s reality in A Sea of Sorrow: A Novel of Odysseus. 

But even if we take the story at face value–that Circe commands Odysseus to take her to bed–at no time do we picture Circe as a young girl. She is clearly a grown woman. Despite being stripped of her power by Hermes and Odysseus, she is a strong “goddess-witch” in her own right. She does what she must to survive and protect her people and her isle. She even helps Odysseus resume his quest to go home.

So why would the artist call her portrait of a sweet, innocent girl,  Circe? Apparently Cameron inscribed the photo with this partial quote from Milton: “Who knows not Circe/daughter of the sun.”

Still doesn’t answer the question though. All I know is that this child is not Circe. This is how I picture her:

Tamer of Wolves/Survivor/Bad Bitch/GrownWoman

Model Joy Jones by Dark Wolf Photography: https://business.facebook.com/darkwolfphotography/?tn-str=k*F

Keep howling, Circe!

 

 

Comments

  1. Elizabeth D says

    February 23, 2020 at 2:59 pm

    Holy cow! That’s always been a deeply disturbing narrative. e

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Purchase Books by Vicky Alvear Shecter
Young Adult Historical Fiction by Vicky Alvear Shecter

YA Historical Fiction

Middle Grade Mythology Books by Vicky Alvear Shecter

Middle Grade Mythology

Middle Grade Biography by author Vicky Alvear Shecter

Middle Grade Biography

A Day of Fire: A Novel of Pompeii by author Vicky Alvear Shecter

Adult Historical Fiction

Vicky Alvear Shecter

Vicky Alvear Shecter is the award-winning author of Young Adult Fiction

When I was a kid, I wanted to be an archaeologist. By the time I entered college, I had forgotten my dreams of digging in the dirt and ended up with a degree … [Read More...]

Follow Vicky

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on PinterestFollow Us on TumblrFollow Us on Goodreads

Recent Posts

Elvis Never Left the Building!

It’s Women’s History Month So Let’s Talk Kick-Butt Ancient Warrior Queens!

Wait, This is a CHILD, not Circe!

  • Privacy Policy

© Copyright 2015-2021 · All Rights Reserved · Website by TecAdvocates